Willfully - Legally Binding Wills for Australians

Making decisions for a loved one who can no longer make them for themselves is a tough spot to be in. It's a situation many of us might face, and trying to figure out the legal side of it all can feel like a huge weight. That’s where guardianship comes in. It's a legal framework in NSW set up to protect and support people who have lost the ability to make their own choices.

Getting your head around this process is really important, whether you're planning for your own future or trying to help someone right now. This guide will walk you through what guardianship actually means, the different kinds you might come across, how the application process works with the Tribunal, and what a guardian is really responsible for.

What is Guardianship in NSW?

So, what are we actually talking about when we say "guardianship"? At its heart, a Guardianship Order is a legal document from the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) that gives someone the authority to make decisions on behalf of another person.

Basically, it lets a person, called a guardian, make decisions about someone else's healthcare, lifestyle, and services they get. This is for situations where a person has a disability that affects their ability to make these key decisions for themselves.

One thing to get straight right away: a guardian does not handle money. That's a common mix-up. Financial matters are dealt with separately under what's called a Financial Management Order. Guardianship is purely about personal and lifestyle decisions.

Everything a guardian does is guided by the principles of the Guardianship Act 1987. Think of these as the ground rules:

The person's well-being and best interests are always the top priority.
Their freedom should be restricted as little as possible.
They should be encouraged to live a normal life in the community.
Their own views and wishes have to be heard and taken into account.

For NCAT to even consider making an order, they first have to be satisfied that someone is a "person in need of a guardian." This means that because of a disability, they're either completely or partially unable to manage their own personal affairs.

Understanding the different types of guardianship in NSW

Guardianship isn't a one-size-fits-all kind of deal. There are a few different types in NSW, and each one is for a different situation. Let's break them down.

Enduring guardianship: Planning for the future

This is the one you set up yourself, just in case. An Enduring Guardian is someone you appoint while you still have your full decision-making capacity. It's a way of planning ahead and picking a trusted person to make decisions for you if you ever lose that ability down the road.

The key thing here is that the appointment only kicks in if and when you can no longer make your own decisions. You can appoint anyone you trust who is over 18. It’s all done on a specific legal form that needs to be witnessed by a qualified lawyer or another approved professional.

It's also good to know that certain life events can automatically cancel an Enduring Guardianship. For example, as laid out in the Guardianship Act, if you get married, your appointment is cancelled unless you happen to marry your guardian. Your appointee can also resign, but if you've already lost capacity, they'll need NCAT's permission to do so.

Guardianship orders: When NCAT intervenes

Sometimes, a person loses their ability to make decisions without having an Enduring Guardian already in place. When that happens, NCAT might need to step in and appoint someone.

Private Guardian: This is usually the first choice for NCAT. They'll look for a suitable family member, a close friend, or a carer who can take on the role. It’s someone who already knows the person well and is willing and able to act in their best interests.
Public Guardian: Think of the Public Guardian as the guardian of last resort. NCAT will only appoint this public official if there's no one else suitable. This might happen if there's serious family conflict, or if the person just doesn't have anyone in their life who can take on the role.

Comparing the types of guardianship

Feature	Enduring Guardian	Private Guardian (by NCAT Order)	Public Guardian (by NCAT Order)
How they are appointed	By the individual while they have capacity.	By NCAT after capacity is lost.	By NCAT as a last resort.
When appointment takes effect	When the individual loses decision-making capacity.	Immediately upon NCAT's order.	Immediately upon NCAT's order.
Who can be appointed	A trusted person over 18 chosen by the individual.	A suitable family member, friend, or carer over 18.	A public official.
Typical Duration	Ongoing until revoked, the person passes away, or by NCAT order.	For a set term, typically up to 1 or 3 years. Renewals can be up to 5 years in some cases.	For a set term, typically up to 1 or 3 years. Renewals can be up to 5 years in some cases.

The NCAT process for appointing a guardian

So, how does NCAT actually decide to appoint a guardian? It’s a formal process with clear steps to make sure the final decision is the right one for the person involved.

When is a guardianship order made?

Appointing a guardian is a serious step. It takes away some of a person's rights, so it’s always seen as a last resort. Disability advocates emphasize that it should only happen after other, less restrictive options, like supported decision-making, have been tried and haven't worked out.

During a hearing, NCAT has a few key questions it needs to answer before making an order:

Does the person have a disability?
Is this disability making them totally or partially incapable of managing their own decisions?
Is there a real, demonstrated need for a guardian to be appointed right now?
If the answer to all of those is yes, then who should it be, what decisions can they make, and for how long?

The application and hearing process

Anyone with a genuine concern for a person's well-being can fill out an application and send it to the Guardianship Division of NCAT.

Once an application is in, a hearing is scheduled. This isn't like a courtroom drama you see on TV.

It's run by a panel of three NCAT members who have a mix of legal, disability-related, and community experience. They look at all the evidence, which can include reports from doctors and other professionals, and they listen to everyone involved: the person the application is about, their family, friends, and carers.

A workflow diagram showing the application and hearing process for Guardianship in NSW at the NCAT.

Most people represent themselves at the hearing. If you want a lawyer to represent you, you have to ask for NCAT's permission in writing at least five working days before the hearing date.

A guardian's role, responsibilities, and the review process

Being a guardian comes with specific duties and clear boundaries. It's not about taking over someone's life, but about giving support where it's needed most. Understanding these responsibilities, and knowing about the alternatives, is key for everyone involved.

What a guardian does (and doesn't do)

A Guardianship Order gives the guardian the authority to make decisions about specific areas of a person's life, which are called 'functions'. These can include deciding:

Where the person lives: This could mean their own home, with family, or in aged care.
What services they receive: This covers things like in-home care, therapy, or community programs.
Consenting to medical and dental treatment: This is for non-routine treatments.

An infographic outlining the responsibilities and limitations of Guardianship in NSW, detailing what a guardian can and cannot do.

But just as important is what a guardian can't do. They are strictly forbidden from making financial decisions, managing property, writing or changing a will for the person, or giving consent for them to get married. These are personal rights that are protected.

Supported decision-making: The preferred alternative

Before even considering guardianship, the first and best option is always supported decision-making. This approach is all about giving a person the help they need to make their own choices. It’s based on the idea that making decisions is a fundamental human right, and a disability shouldn't take that away.

An infographic comparing supported decision-making with Guardianship in NSW, highlighting the focus on empowerment and personal choice.

This support can look different for different people. It might mean explaining information in a simpler way, using pictures, or having a trusted friend or family member sit in on conversations to help them weigh up the options. The goal is to empower the person and respect their independence.

There are great resources out there to help with this, like the Council for Intellectual Disability's work on the My Rights Matter Project, which offers information and training on how to put supported decision-making into practice.

How guardianship orders are reviewed

Guardianship Orders aren't forever. NCAT appoints guardians for a set amount of time. The Guardianship Act 1987 states that an initial order is typically for up to one year, and renewals are usually for up to three years (though it can be up to five in some special cases).

Before an order expires, NCAT will generally review it to see if it's still needed. Things can change, and a person's ability to make decisions might improve. The person under guardianship, their guardian, the Public Guardian, or anyone else with a genuine concern can also ask for a review at any time if circumstances change.

After a review, NCAT can decide to renew the order as it is, change it, or let it end if it's no longer necessary or in the person's best interests.

To see how these principles and processes work in a real-life scenario, the following video from the Department of Communities and Justice NSW provides a helpful case study on applying for guardianship and financial management through NCAT.

Navigating Guardianship in NSW can seem complicated, but it's a vital legal process designed to protect some of the most vulnerable people in our community. Whether it's planning for the future with an Enduring Guardian or an order made by NCAT when a crisis hits, the system is there to provide a safety net.

The biggest takeaway should be the importance of planning ahead. Appointing an Enduring Guardian while you have the capacity is the best way to ensure your wishes are known and that someone you trust is in charge.

And remember, guardianship is always the last resort. The focus should always be on supported decision-making first, to uphold a person's independence and right to choose for as long as possible.

If you're facing this situation, it's always a good idea to get professional legal advice tailored to your circumstances. For more information, official resources from NCAT and the NSW Trustee and Guardian are the best places to start.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the first step to applying for Guardianship in NSW?

The first step is to submit an application to the Guardianship Division of the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT). Anyone with a genuine concern for the person's welfare can apply, and there are no fees for the application.

Who can be appointed for Guardianship in NSW?

NCAT prefers to appoint a private guardian, such as a family member, close friend, or carer over the age of 18. If no suitable person is available, NCAT may appoint the Public Guardian as a last resort.

Can a person with Guardianship in NSW still make their own decisions?

Yes, as much as possible. A core principle of the law is to limit a person's freedom as little as possible. The guardian should always consider the person's views and encourage them to participate in decisions that affect their life.

How long does an order for Guardianship in NSW typically last?

An initial order is usually made for up to one year. If it's reviewed and renewed, the renewal period is typically for up to three years, though it can be up to five years in certain situations. The order is always reviewed to ensure it's still necessary.

What's the difference between Enduring Guardianship and Guardianship in NSW appointed by NCAT?

Enduring Guardianship is something you set up yourself while you have full capacity, choosing who you want to make decisions for you later. A guardianship order from NCAT is made when a person has already lost capacity and doesn't have an Enduring Guardian in place.

Does Guardianship in NSW cover financial decisions?

No, it does not. A guardian's role is strictly limited to personal and lifestyle decisions, like where a person lives and what healthcare they receive. Financial matters are handled separately under a Financial Management Order.